The theme of the September 11 issue of The New Yorker is "Five Years After," and the cover art is haunting, beautiful, and mysterious. I was looking forward to hearing the magazine's cover editor, Francoise Mouly, dispel some of the mystery in her interview last week on the public radio program "The World." Big disappointment. For someone who makes her living selecting and (I assume) critiquing art for one of the most literate magazines in the English-speaking world, Mouly was distressingly inarticulate. When program host Lisa Mullins asked Mouly to describe the cover, Mouly demurred, "It's hard to describe an image...I'll try to describe the experience."
And she proceeded to say very little that would help, say, a blind person imagine what the cover is about.
"It's hard to describe an image"? Oh, please. Historians and art critics do it every day. Heck, ordinary people do it on the telephone. I find it disingenuous when people in the image business--art directors, graphic designers, photographers--claim, as they often do, that "words can't express" what they do, or that "the work speaks for itself." Every picture tells a story, folks; and when you're doing a radio interview, your speaking-for-itself work needs a ventriloquist.
As a person in the word trade, I've taken pains to learn some basic vocabulary to communicate with my design counterparts; I'm hardly an expert, but I can talk confidently about white space, sans-serif fonts, drop shadows, full bleeds, and more. I don't think it's too much to ask that picture people learn some storytelling techniques of their own.
For the record, here's what Mouly might have told the radio audience but didn't:
"It's a double cover." Incredibly, neither Mouly nor Mullins mentioned this fact, which is the issue's most salient feature.
"On the first cover, right under the magazine's logo, we see a small figure of a man against a white background. He's holding a slightly curved bar, and his feet dangle in space." Mouly called the image on the cover a silhouette; it isn't. (Amazing that Mouly didn't even use this art term--and she's French! and it's a French word!--correctly.) We clearly see the man's face, which bears a serene expression, eyes downcast, lips smiling slightly.
"When you turn the page, you see a second cover--in brilliant color--that fills in the background that's missing on the white cover." That background is the Manhattan cityscape, with the hollow footprints of the vanished World Trade Center directly beneath the suspended man's dangling feet. Now we begin to grasp the full import of the image, and those of us with long memories will recognize the floating man for who he is.
Mouly did tell this part of the story: On August 24, 1974, a 24-year-old French high-wire artist, Philippe Petit, walked on a steel cable he had surreptitiously attached between the still-unfinished Twin Towers, 1,350 feet above the ground. One hundred thousand people gathered below, and traffic stopped while Petit traversed the 130-foot gap eight times. (Petit published a book about the feat, To Reach the Clouds, in 2002. And animator Michael Sporn made a movie about it; Sporn blogs about the current cover art, and the deeply memorable 2001 Art Spiegelman New Yorker cover, here.)
Here's another interesting fact about the double cover that Mouly didn't mention (I'll be charitable and propose that it was edited out): Two artists share credit for it. This is highly unusual, if not unique, for The New Yorker, and I wondered whether one artist did the top cover and the second did the underlay, or whether the two worked as a team on both images.
Neither, as I discovered when I did a little poking around.
Bay Area artist John Mavroudis was responsible for the cover concept, which he submitted--along with many other ideas for a 9/11 tribute--to The New Yorker. Go here to see his rejected ideas, along with his comments (see? artists can talk about their work!) and a beautifully animated rendition of the version that succeeded. That cover was ultimately rendered by Owen Smith, a children's book illustrator and frequent New Yorker cover artist who also lives near San Francisco; Mavroudis is generous in his praise of Smith's work. Mavroudis and Smith have never met.